The problem I have with a lot of the J2 fics I've read is that they are what I would call out of character. I realise that makes no sense since it's RPS so they're not really characters but you know what I mean? There's a lot of stuff that has the boys crying all the time and acting like teenage girls.
Anyway, I finally found one that I liked. It's dark, but amazingly well written and all the characters featured actually feel like real people
Intimate EnemyIt's long but well worth the read if you haven't read it before.