Season four of Supernatural was voted as the best with 37% of the vote. Season two came a close second with 34%
I'm guessing a lot of the S4 votes were due to Castiel. Am I wrong?
Don't get me wrong, I love Cas (as if that wasn't obvious) but in terms of the overall arc plot I definitely prefer the earlier seasons.
Season 1 is probably my favourite, even though a lot of the storylines were formulaic and predicatable. Episodes of S1 scared me which is the closest I've come to having any sort of emotional reaction to the show, apart from the ones that make me laugh of course.
S2 is definitly a close second and in fact it's probably more well structured than S1.
The less said about S3 the better. I think the fact that only two people voted for it says a lot